Echoes of a Forsaken Heart novel Chapter 186

Natalie paused, a fleeting look of regret crossing her features.

She gave a small, apologetic laugh. "I'm sorry, Ryan, it's just not possible."

Ryan's face was a portrait of pain. "Natalie, don't you even want to try for me?"

Her gaze dropped. "I can try, Ryan, but I can't give up everything, I'm sorry."

She truly couldn't.

She couldn't abandon the life she had fought so hard to build. Nor could she neglect Tatiana for anyone's sake. And of course, she couldn't ask Ryan to give up his promising future and happy family for her. What right did she have to demand such a sacrifice from him?

She didn't believe she had that allure, nor did she want a relationship built on debts.

"But you were the one who wanted to start this relationship!" Ryan felt wronged.

Natalie now regretted her impulsiveness. "Ryan, I really am sorry. I thought we could go the distance, but I oversimplified things. If we step back now, we can still be friends. If we force it, we'll only end up resenting each other."

"So, I'm sorry, Ryan, but let's break up."

Ryan's eyes were red, and after a moment he asked, "Can we still be friends, then?"

Natalie nodded softly. "Of course."

Ryan started to reach out to her, as if to pat her head, but halfway through, he seemed to remember something and let his hand drop back to his side.

"I'll keep my promise, Natalie. On New Year's Eve, I'll come over for the fireworks."

Natalie blinked, surprised. "You don't have to. It's an important day; you should stay home with your family."

But Ryan insisted, "It's my one wish now, Natalie. I want to spend the holiday with you."

Natalie frowned.

Ryan just smiled. "Natalie, I won't give up. I'm choosing to break up because I don't want my family to hurt you anymore, but I'll keep trying until they accept us."

Natalie was stunned. "Ryan, I'm not worth it."

"I think you are," he said with a tender smile.

Before Natalie could respond, Ryan gave her a smile and walked away.

She furrowed her brow, wanting to call after him but ultimately remained silent.

She couldn't persuade him; some things were beyond words. She had to let him come to terms with it himself.

After Ryan disappeared, Natalie decided to head back.

But she hadn't gone far when she heard a car door opening nearby, and a man stepped out.

Hamilton quickly approached her.

Recognizing the newcomer, Natalie's mood instantly darkened.

This devious man had been lurking nearby, witnessing the entire exchange. And he even had the nerve to smile. "I told you it wouldn't last."

Already feeling raw, Natalie's temper flared at his words. "Yes, but that doesn't mean it's your turn!"

With that, she turned to leave.

Hamilton grabbed her arm, stopping her. "Not my turn? Who then? Ronin? He's even less reliable. What can that kid offer you? Natalie, be with me. Whatever you want, I'll give it to you."

His words infuriated her. "Who says I need to be with a man at all? Let me put it this way: I'd rather be single for life than have anything to do with you again!"

She pushed him away, but he pulled her close, anger in his eyes.

"Why can he have you and not me?"

Natalie glared back. "What do you think, Hamilton? You want me back, and then what? To continue being your mistress? A perpetual secret, never good enough to be seen in public? Is that it?"

Hamilton's face stiffened, suddenly at a loss for words.

Natalie sneered and turned to leave.

Hamilton caught her again. "What do you want from me, Natalie?"

She faced him squarely. "I want someone who loves me wholeheartedly. Can you give me that devotion, that love?"

He was silent.

"If you can't, then stay out of my life. I'm done playing canary for you," Natalie snapped, and she walked away.

But as she left, she couldn't deny that Hamilton still had the power to upset her. She hadn't felt this hurt even after breaking up with Ryan, but Hamilton's few words reopened old wounds.