Her Cancellation of the Engagement novel Chapter 85

Chapter 85 Investigation

Alisa also took a day off today. She didn't need to be present during this meeting but wanted to witness Sherman's family in distress, so she stayed home with Brenna.

Throughout the conversation between Sherman and Brenna, Alisa remained silent. In such circumstances, the elders spoke, and she didn't feel interjecting was appropriate.

She didn't expect Sherman to suddenly shift the topic to her and ask her to choose.

She clenched her fists, her lips pressed tightly, and tears welled in her eyes, appearing as if she felt wronged. "Dad, are you also cutting ties with me?"

Sherman's expression remained unchanged, and he said, "I'm asking you to make a choice. If you choose me, you can't come to Geller's villa anymore. If you choose your grandmother, you can't come to see me in the future. Alisa, you can't have the best of both worlds. You must choose between me and your grandmother."

He intended to let Alisa make a choice.

He had observed Alisa's behavior, character, and actions over the years and was genuinely disappointed.

Especially after Gianna's return, Alisa's actions had let him down.

Now that he and Brenna had to go separate ways, his adopted daughter, Alisa, also had to make a choice.

"Dad, why did you have to go up against Grandma? You two used to get along well. Grandma is getting old, and she has her reasons. You adopted me, but I've always considered you and Mom my biological parents. I hope we can live happily together."

With teary eyes, Alisa continued, "I know Gianna has been resentful of me since she came back. She thinks I've taken everything that belonged to her. But I didn't do it willingly. Dad, can't you please not cut ties with Grandma? I don't want to leave you!"

Sherman's brow furrowed, and he scolded in a low voice, "Enough!"

His words almost came out as a shout, and Alisa had never seen him so frightened. She trembled in fear.

"Gianna has never been resentful of you. She never even mentioned you at home. How did you get the idea that she's angry with you for taking away everything? Alisa, ask yourself, during the two years you lived in my house, didn't your mom and I sacrifice our needs to provide for you? Calvin is my biological son, and sometimes, even he went hungry, but I've never starved you."

Alisa kept her head down and didn't speak.

But a hint of sarcasm flashed in her eyes, unnoticed by anyone.

If she could choose, she wouldn't have wanted to be adopted by Sherman. They were always struggling financially, while the members of the Geller family lived a life of luxury. The young ladies of the Geller family wore designer clothes, while she could only afford a few hundred-dollar outfits.

That's why she had tried to please Brenna and be brought back to the Geller family. She didn't think she was wrong. Who wouldn't want to climb the social ladder?

She was just born with a less privileged background compared to Gianna; if she had a better background, she would be even more outstanding than she was now.

"We don't have much money, but since you came here, I've done everything I could to treat you well. I admit I had selfish motives. I treated you well also because I hoped someone would treat Gia as well as I treated you. But honestly, I've never mistreated you. Instead, you have constantly complained that we didn't give you the best!"

"Dad, that's not what I meant," Alisa said impatiently.

She didn't want to hear his lectures.

If Sherman weren't still helpful to her, she would have wished for them to cut ties with Brenna already.

"That's enough. I can tell you're getting impatient," Sherman glanced at her calmly. "Now, make your choice. Stay or go, and it's up to you."

Alisa pursed her lips, a touch of coldness flashing in her eyes, but she still appeared aggrieved. "Do we have to do this? Can't you get along?"

"Yes, we have to do this," Sherman replied seriously.

"Then... I choose Grandma," Alisa hesitated for a few seconds before deciding.